« Previous | Next » 

Revision 5fd6b694


Added by Michael Hanselmann almost 12 years ago

jqueue: Keep jobs in “waitlock” while returning to queue

Iustin Pop reported that a job's file is updated many times while it
waits for locks held by other thread(s). After an investigation it was
concluded that the reason was a design decision for job priorities to
return jobs to the “queued” status if they couldn't acquire all locks.
Changing a jobs' status or priority requires an update to permanent

In a high-level view this is what happens:
1. Mark as waitlock
2. Write to disk as permanent storage (jobs left in this state by a
crashing master daemon are resumed on restart)
3. Wait for lock (assume lock is held by another thread)
4. Mark as queued
5. Write to disk again
6. Return to workerpool

Another option originally discussed was to leave the job in the
“waitlock” status. Ignoring priority changes, this is what would happen:
1. If not in waitlock
1.1. Assert state queued
1.2. Mark as waitlock
1.3. Set start_timestamp
1.4. Write to disk as permanent storage
3. Wait for locks (assume lock is held by another thread)
4. Leave in waitlock
5. Return to workerpool

Now let's assume the lock is released by the other thread:
3. Wait for locks and get them
4. Assert state waitlock
5. Set state to running
6. Set exec_timestamp
7. Write to disk

As this change reduces the number of writes from two per lock acquire
attempt to two per opcode and one per priority increase (as happens
after 24 acquire attempts (see mcpu._CalculateLockAttemptTimeouts) until
the highest priority is reached), here's the patch to implement it.
Unittests are updated.

Signed-off-by: Michael Hanselmann <>
Reviewed-by: Iustin Pop <>


  • added
  • modified
  • copied
  • renamed
  • deleted

View differences